Subscribe to our weekly newsletters
Subscribe to newsletter

 

Editor's Note: Eaton Electric provide:-

Earth connectionsEarth connections
Earth wiringEarth wiring
Terminal connectors Terminal connectors
Electrical switchgearElectrical switchgear

Request Information

Home
Include Article
Advertise
 

Links
Request Information
Terms of use
Contact

 

Request Facilities / Interiors product information

Request Architectural product information External

Request Architectural product information Internal

Request Mechanical HVAC product information

Request Electrical product information

 

EATON ELECTRIC LTD Earth Connections For RCBOs 

There has been a lot of discussion recently in the press and on-line about RCBOs and, in particular, about the separate earth connection that is used by some of these devices. Unfortunately, a lot of the information that has appeared has been misleading and, in some cases, it is simply wrong. Given that the recent introduction of the 17th Edition of the IEE Wiring Regulations is resulting in a big increase in the usage of RCBOs, it is important to clarify the situation.

One of the most misleading statements, but one that seems to be repeated time and again, is that in order to comply with BS EN 61009, RCBOs must have a separate earth connection. This is not true. Certainly, the standard specifies that an RCBO that does have a separate earth connection must behave in a certain way, but nowhere does it state or imply that a separate earth connection is mandatory.

In fact, RCBOs are currently available that have no separate earth connection, yet they achieve full compliance with the standard, supported with declaration of conformity documents.

Another often-made point is that, without a separate earth connection, an RCBO cannot detect an earth fault if the neutral becomes disconnected. This is true, but in reality it is not an issue worthy of consideration.

Losing the neutral connection is a rare event in itself, especially in the TN-C and TN-C-S systems that are almost invariably used today. The probability of losing the neutral and having an earth fault at the same time, a double fault condition, is vanishingly small Ė certainly so small that there is no reason to take it into account when specifying protection devices.

In spite of this, there are those who claim that itís still better to use an RCBO with a separate earth connection, ďjust to be on the safe sideĒ. This is not necessarily a good judgement call. The extra connection means that consumer units and distribution boards take longer to wire, which pushes up costs. Even worse, many contractors donít seem to know what to do with the earth connection, as a search of the on-line electrical forums will quickly reveal. In fact, there have been suggestions that some contractors have actually been cutting off the earth wires, which has to be very bad practice for an RCBO thatís been designed and tested on the basis that it will be earthed.

Finally, thereís the thorny issue of testing. Most if not all manufacturers of RCBOs with earth connections insist that these connections are removed during insulation testing to avoid possible damage to the RCBO, and during loop testing to eliminate the possibility of misleading test results. Removing and replacing the connections adds more time and cost, of course, but there are also other concerns.

First, there is always the possibility that the contractor will forget to reconnect the earth wires, leaving the RCBO operating under conditions different from those for which it was designed. Second, disconnecting the earth wires goes against one of the basic principles of installation testing, which is that installations should in exactly the same state when they are tested as they will be when they are in service.

Claiming that a separate earth connection is essential on RCBOs is not only wrong, it also makes life unnecessarily complicated for contractors, while trying to protect against a risk thatís theoretical rather than real. Protection products should always be selected with care, but they should be selected on the basis of performance and reliability rather than on the basis of some invented and imaginary criterion.

Email: literature-info@eaton.com


Wavin Drainage system Water drainage systems Drainage inspection chamber News 100510

Honeywell Balancing valve Automatic balancing valves Pressure balance valve News 100510

Mitsubishi Ventilation systems Energy efficient heating Air heat exchangers News 100510

Terrys Eyelet curtains Interior design blog Ready made curtains News 100510

Vent Axia Ventilation systems Energy efficient ventilation Recovery ventilation systems News 100510

Recticel Insulation products Closed cell insulation Thermal insulation products News 100510

Cooltherm Cooling system Chiller installation System cooling Water chillers News 100510

Cablofil Cable management system Steel wire tray Tray cable News 110510

Armstrong Plant rooms Hvac system Variable speed drive pumps News 110510

GE Consumer Electric meters Power meters Smart meter Control products News 110510

Harlequin Dance studio floor Vinyl flooring Blue dance floor News 110510

Oracle Storage systems Medical records storage Data storage systems News 110510

Wavin Plumbing fittings Plumbing pipe Push fittings Pipe fittings News 120510

Eurobrick Tile cladding Stone faced cladding Brick slip cladding News 120510

Flakt Woods Air handling units Energy solutions Air handling systems News 120510

Eaton Earth connections Earth wiring Terminal connectors Electrical switchgear News 120510

Actionair Air diffusion grilles Fire dampers Grilles diffusers louvres News 120510

Air Diffusion Cooling systems Low energy ventilation Computer floor grille News 120510

3M Respirator mask 3m respirator Asbestos respirator Asbestos mask News 120510

Formica Product life cycle assessment Lca products Lca analysis News 120510

Clark Drain covers Recessed drain covers Plastic drain covers News 120510

Flakt Woods Air diffusers Air handling units Air handling systems News 130510

Flowcrete Floor finishes Epoxy flooring Resin floor Floor screed News 130510

Urban Tree planter Green roofs Urban tree Tree planters News 130510

Dimplex Ground heat pumps Heat pumps Water heat pumps News 130510

Oracle Storage systems Office storage systems Room divider units Units 130510

Carlisle Brass Door furniture Door handles Door ironmongery Door backplates News 130510

Klargester Sewage treatment plant Biodisc sewage treatment Sewage drainage News 130510

Actionair Fire protection systems Fire dampers Motorised fire damper News 140510

Hitachi Wall air conditioners Air conditioner Energy efficient cooling News 140510

Tarkett Vinyl flooring Safety flooring Hospital flooring Recycled flooring News 140510

Eurobrick Brick slip cladding Tile cladding Stone faced cladding News 140510

Clark Drain covers Recessed drain covers Drain inspection covers News 140510

Sika Single ply roof Vinyl roofing Roof waterproof membrane News 140510

TBS Fabrications Washroom cubicles Washroom accessories Vanity units Duct panels News 140510

Pulsar Renewable energy systems Plumbing specialists Eco traning courses News 140510

Kalzip Standing seam roofing Low U-value roofing Metal roofing and cladding News 140510

ALC Lighting controls Light sensors Automatic lighting Area controllers News 140510

Mapei Floor tile adhesives Floor sealant Solvent-free adhesives News 140510

HCP Heating specialists Radiant heating Heating systems Heating panels News 140510

Timberplay Outdoor playground equipment Wooden playground equipment Play facilities News 140510

Marshall Tufflex Light energy saving Cable trays Cable tray systems News 170510

Weatherite Commercial kitchen ventilation Air conditioning Kitchen ventilation equipment News 170510

Leaderflush Shapland Doorsets Fire doors Veneered doors Internal doors News 170510

Dulux Dulux paint Exterior paint Trade paint Weathershield paint News 170510

Harlequin Portable dance floors Sprung dance floors Dance floors News 170510

Jeld-Wen Wood veneer doors Real wood veneer Internal doors News 170510

Klober Roofing materials Roofing tiles Roofing supplies Cpd presentation News 180510

Levolux Solar shading Ventilation louvres Curtain walling Timber fins News 180510

Armacell Armaflex insulation Bacteria protection Duct insulation Pipework insulation News 180510

Terrys Curtain poles Curtain fabrics Eyelet curtains Interior design News 180510

Schuco Energy saving windows Aluminium windows Super insulated windows News 190510

Sureset Resin bound paving Paving products Block paving driveways News 190510

Trend Energy management systems Electricity meters Variable speed News 190510

Socomec Electrical switchgear Power quality Uninterruptible power News 200510

Riegens Industrial lighting Exterior lights Safety lights Commercial News 200510

Dorma Swing doors Entrance doors Exterior sliding doors News 200510

Marshall Tufflex Electrical wiring Wiring systems Cable trunking Cable installation News 210510

Leaderflush Doorset manufacturer Timber doors Doors internal Doors external News 210510

Dow Roof insulation Floor insulation Sound insulation Insulation material News 210510

Blinds UK Window blinds Window treatments Internal blinds Blinds manufacturers News 210510

Gooding Group Wardrobe sliding doors Wardrobes systems Sliding wardrobes doors News 210510

SSQ Slate roof tiles Natural stone flooring Slate sculpture News 210510

Harlequin Sprung dance floors Dance floor Dance studio floor News 210510

Action Storage Storage shelves Shelving systems Shelving storage Storage equipment News 210510

Morgan Lovell Office design Office refurbishment services Office space design News 210510

Arundel Jones Associates Ltd Registered in England and Wales No. 07334149
Hill Farm, Linton Hill, Maidstone, Kent ME 17 4AL
Tel : 01622 745333 email
copyright all rights reserved

News Categories : Earth connections
Earth wiring Terminal connectors
Electrical switchgear